How to know if you are a good writer

  • Self-doubt is a natural part of a writer's journey, even for the most celebrated authors.
  • Constructive criticism helps identify areas for improvement, while positive feedback can validate one's skills and build confidence.
  • Consistently producing high-quality content and maintaining a steady voice across different themes and topics are indicators of a good writer.
  • A strong grasp of grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure is fundamental to effective writing.

Have you ever sat down after hours of typing, looked at the results, and wondered, "Am I really a good writer?" Doubts often creep into our minds, especially when we embark on an endeavour that stirs passion - like writing. In this article, we'll dissect this question completely. We will shed light on the nuanced characteristics that define 'good' in relation to writing and provide actionable tips for self-assessment. My aim? To help transform those nagging doubts into solid confidence or propel you towards improving your craft. Ponder with me on the indicators of being a good writer!

Why do I doubt my writing abilities?

Self-doubt is as common to writers as ink stains are to old-fashioned quills -- it's very much part of the process. Shakespeare himself likely tussled with concerns regarding his manuscripts! While frustrating, self-doubt shouldn't be seen solely as negative; it can also push us towards betterment.

Why does this happen? Paradoxically, improving your skills can lead to more doubts surfacing since improvement generally involves a heightened awareness of any shortfall in abilities. Increased exposure to exceptional work by others might intensify feelings of inadequacy too, even though comparison isn’t always helpful or fair.

Remember: Even established authors didn't start off penning masterpieces – they experienced numerous trials and errors before developing their unique voices and thriving in their respective genres.

Striving for perfection

Perfectionism could also be a significant factor contributing to this self-doubt. As writers, we often aim to create a perfect piece - one that's free from grammatical errors, speaks directly to its audience, and just flows naturally. However, since 'perfection' is largely subjective in the writing realm, striving for such unattainable standards can lead us to incorrectly conclude "my writing isn't good enough." 

When we compare our work with established authors and their bestsellers (forgetting that they too once were beginners), our own words seem insignificant which further amplifies the feelings of self-doubt.

Fear of failure

Another potential cause for questioning oneself—"Is my writing good?"—is fear of failure. With every story you pen down comes the risk of rejection—by publishers, readers, or both. You might dread negative feedback or criticism—however constructive it may be—inability to meet publication deadlines or struggle to find suitable ideas for new projects; all these instances just compound your uncertainties.

Given such an emotional roller-coaster ride native to a writer’s journey, doubting one’s abilities becomes understandable if not inevitable.

Here's what we must remember, though: Self-doubt isn’t entirely bad or unproductive. In fact, it can work as a motivator to achieve more—to 'be' more. It prevents you from becoming too complacent and spurs continual learning instead. You just need to channel these doubts into something constructive, which in turn, helps you validate your writing prowess.


An essential first step to identifying whether you're a good writer or not is self-assessment. This includes scrutinising your work critically but constructively, understanding the impact of your writing on readers, and assessing your knowledge about the fundamentals of writing.

Feedback from others

One reliable method to gauge your writing prowess is by seeking feedback from others - be it peers, mentors, or even your audience. It's invaluable to have a range of perspectives on the quality of your storytelling, coherence in thought flow, language appropriateness and influence on reader cognition.

  • Positive feedback usually indicates that you are indeed good at communicating via written words.
  • Constructive criticism helps identify areas for improvement and thus emphasises "how to tell if you’re a good writer". 

Considering these points allows you not only external validation but also gives you vital inputs for elevating your skills.


The next critical factor where assessment can hint at how well you're doing as a writer is consistency. Being proficient in writing isn't a one-off granting title; maintaining consistent delivery in terms of quality content defines a good writer. Assess whether:

  1. Your voice remains steady throughout different themes or topics.
  2. You consistently generate intriguing content that engages readers.
  3. You regularly practise writing and refining it based on acquired insights.

A high level of consistency often implies established routines and habits around drafting, editing, and proofreading—elements distinguishing excellent writers from mediocre ones.

Understanding of Writing Mechanics

Lastly, understanding the mechanics—grammar rules, punctuation usage, sentence structure—is pivotal for any successful writer. Good grasp over these aspects demonstrates a strong foundation upon which effective narrative building lies.

For example:

  • Are sentences neatly structured with appropriate use of clauses?
  • Is there suitable usage of punctuation marks ensuring lucidity in text flow? 
  • Are tenses used rightly to convey intended occurrences?

Answering such queries may help determine if your writing capabilities are well-honed. Not to forget, with evolving languages and styles, even seasoned writers often brush up their knowledge of mechanics.

Remember: A writer's journey is one of continuous learning and refining skills. As long as you're open to constructive criticism, persistent in your practice, and have a clear grasp of essential writing elements, rest assured—you’re advancing towards being an excellent writer.

External validation

When looking for indicators to answer the gnawing question, "How do I know if I'm a good writer?" it’s helpful to extend your gaze outward. That is to say, consider external factors: in addition to self-assessment and feedback from acquaintances, credible third-party validation can give you solid proof of your writing prowess.

Publication acceptance

Publication isn't an exclusive function of established authors anymore. So when discussing publication acceptance as an indication of skill, this spans beyond traditionally published books. This includes articles featured in renowned platforms or recognised blogs, poetry featured in anthologies or publishers accepting your manuscript submissions. 

Each acceptance acts as a badge of approval from professionals in the industry who have found your work worthy enough. It authenticates that not only does your work maintain high standards but also bodes well with readership preferences.

Book sales

Moving forward on our road map to self-discovery, let's touch upon something quite basic yet critical - book sales. While they’re largely influenced by marketing strategies and public relations efforts apart from writing quality per se; consistent high sales undoubtedly signal popular appreciation for your work.

Let me make clear here, though—low sales don’t necessarily mean poor-quality writing. Significant sales records indicate that you've successfully engaged the audience and resonated with their mindset—key traits of a good writer!

Book reviews from readers

Taking a step forward, delve into the intimate realm of reader experiences – reviews posted on platforms such as Goodreads or Amazon by real readers (not critics) offer rich insight into how successful you've been in connecting with your audience through words.

Reviews highlight whether readers understood what you were conveying and whether they could empathise with you as you laid out the journey—becoming invaluable markers of skill assessment.

Awards and Recognition

Seek solace in external acknowledgement: accolades, contests won or simply being shortlisted for prestigious awards are robust indicators of your writing ability. Such recognition not only indicates a high standard of quality but also demonstrates that your work has touched and inspired others in the literary community.

While it's vital not to base your entire self-worth on awards, as they can often be influenced by changing societal trends or judges' individual biases — being honoured in this way is unquestionably noteworthy in terms of evaluating whether you're a proficient writer. 

In conclusion, while gauging one’s strength as a writer is indeed complex; adopting strategies such as seeking external validation offers clear indicators about where we stand. It’s all part of the journey of becoming an author who crafts words that hold power: power to engage minds and touch hearts!

Personal growth

When one explores the question, "How do I know if I'm a good writer", personal growth plays an integral role. After all, writing is more than just coherence of thoughts and language manipulation; it's about maturity and consistency over time. This section focuses on two critical aspects that denote personal growth as a writer - the improvement seen in your work over time and the unwavering passion and persistence that keep you tethered to this art form.

Improvement over time

Literary prowess isn't accomplished overnight. It flourishes gradually with consistent practice, learning and immeasurable patience. As you write more, you begin to notice improved sentence structures, vocabulary usage, flow of thoughts among other mechanics of writing.

  1. Revisit past works: One effective way to measure improvement is by revisiting your old drafts or published pieces. Look for variations in your style, voice or tone.
  2. Attention to detail: A heightened sense of observation is another indicator of progression. You might find yourself making fewer grammatical mistakes or getting better at catching slip-ups before publishing.
  3. Richer storytelling: A tangible enhancement in connecting with readers through storytelling could also signal progress.

Always remember, incremental advancement may seem negligible when viewed daily but can be staggering when assessed over a lengthier span.

Passion and persistence

"What does it take to be a good writer?" Many would argue that having an unquenchable passion for conjuring narratives from thin air aligns well with the answer. If you are genuinely excited about threading words together into a meaningful tapestry regardless of recognition or monetary reward, then count that as yet another sign in your favour!

  1. Enthusiasm during trying times: Do setbacks frustrate you but simultaneously inspire determination? Then, these trials are merely honing your skills.
  2. Energy despite exhaustion: If even after exhaustive days, drafting sentences electrifies rather than drains you and fills your mind with serenity, you are on the right path towards mastery.
  3. Everlasting quest for learning: The constant exploration of diverse writing styles, genres and attending writing workshops signal passion and persistence.

Your strength lies not in never falling but in rising with every splash of criticism brimming with renewed love for this craft.

Evaluating personal growth is a definitive way to know if you're evolving as a good writer. Harnessing skills over time coupled with an insatiable hunger to express through words nurtures your innate talent and moulds you into the writer destined inside you.

Signs you're evolving as a writer

Gauging your evolution as a writer is much more than waiting for external validation or glancing at impressive book sales. To truly identify the signs of being a good writer, it's imperative that we delve deeper into our personal growth factors and continuous practices. 

Honing your distinctive voice

One of the key indicators you're developing as a skilled wordsmith lies in your unique "writer’s voice." It's this voice that can set you apart from countless others—a hallmark of a talented writer indeed! So how do I know if I'm honing my distinctive voice?

  • Are your writing pieces imbued with a consistent style?
  • Can readers readily discern your personality through words on the page?  

Such questions might provide insight into whether your tone and style remain consistent across varying platforms — a surefire indicator that it's not only about becoming good at writing but rather shaping an identity through alphabetic expression.

Embracing complex narrative structures

The crux of narrative complexity isn't just about weaving intricate stories. Instead, it encapsulates an understanding of how best to structure one's thoughts. As such, adapting complex narratives tells us how we're evolving—not merely from simple sentences to larger paragraphs—but from single-line concepts into fully fleshed ideas. That said, here's something worthy of your contemplation:

  • Do you find yourself successfully conveying complex characters and plots? 
  • Is transitioning between different timelines or perspectives easier now?

If yes, these positive shifts reveal growth beyond basic storytelling—an alluring facet marking the emergence of a strong writer.

Value in feedback and criticism

Misconceptions often linger around criticism, seen by some novice writers as bruising their creative ego. The reality couldn’t be more different. Part of evolving as writers encompasses gracefully accepting constructive critique—transforming negatives into fuel for growth. Reflect on:

  • How do you react to criticism—do you see it as an opportunity for betterment?
  • Is your writing benefitting from feedback, making revisions easier than before?

If these improvements persist over time, they stand testament to not only receptive thinking but also adapting writing styles—definitely signs of a good writer.

In essence, understanding our progression isn't restricted solely to the accolades we attain but also to coming to terms with how far we've travelled from where we once stood. Irrespective of doubts and difficulties, remember that every step brings us closer to becoming that prolific writer nestled inside each of us. 

This journey towards evolving is packed with highs and lows, but continue to embrace it, as it indeed shapes the writers we're blossoming into. 

Advice from a published writer
This article is always evolving and being updated regularly by our expert writers. Information featured in it has been fact-checked and verified.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form
More resources

Related articles

How to promote your book with video
Read More
Does redesigning a book cover after a few years help sales?
Read More
How to get a book published: 6 steps to success
Read More
Are You Ready?

Order your book cover

If you have any questions or if you're ready to go ahead, please fill out our short design enquiry form.